Will the New York Yankees win more than 86.5 games in the 2026 MLB Regular Season?
🗂 Part of event: MLB: 2026 Regular Season Win Totals →💡 What the odds say
The market puts this at about a 82% chance — likely.
No money — just record your call and see if you were right. Yes is at 82% right now.
Despite strong 82% odds, the Yankees face internal concerns (catching issues, Judge reality) that could threaten their win pace, yet the market may be pricing in a strong start and trade-deadline fixes.
📊 Base rate: Over the past decade (2016-2025), the Yankees have averaged 93 wins per 162-game season, making the 86.5 threshold a relatively low bar for this franchise.
What's driving it
- • The team's catching woes, highlighted by GM Cashman's assessment (Pinstripe Alley, Jul 11), create a clear weakness that could cost games down the stretch.
- • A brutally honest assessment of Aaron Judge's reality (Yahoo Sports, Jul 11) suggests uncertainty around the team's best player, potentially affecting offensive production.
- • The ongoing MLB draft (ESPN, Jul 11) shifts focus to future talent, but does not directly impact this season's win total, leaving current on-field issues as the primary driver.
The case for YES
- • The Yankees have a strong core (Judge, Cole) and likely a winning record so far, putting them on pace to exceed 86.5 wins.
- • The team can address catching issues via trades before the deadline, turning a weakness into a strength.
- • Historical precedent: the Yankees have exceeded 86.5 wins in 8 of the last 10 seasons, suggesting this is a high-probability outcome.
The case for NO
- • Persistent catching problems, as noted by Cashman (Pinstripe Alley, Jul 11), could lead to lost games in close contests.
- • The 'Aaron Judge reality' (Yahoo Sports, Jul 11) may indicate a decline or injury risk that depresses the team's offensive ceiling.
- • Second-half schedule or injuries could derail a team that may already be overperforming relative to underlying metrics.
What to watch
- • MLB trade deadline (July 31, 2026): If the Yankees acquire a catcher, odds likely rise (Yes); if they stand pat, odds may fall (No).
- • Next series vs. division rival (e.g., vs. Red Sox, dates not specified): A poor performance would lower the probability of reaching 87 wins.
- • Release of advanced stats (e.g., FanGraphs playoff odds update around July 15): Could shift market if projections show a decline in win expectancy.
AI-generated · grounded in recent news + odds · informational only, not advice. Verify on the source platform.
Data from Polymarket’s public API, for informational purposes only. PredictPal is not affiliated with any platform and does not facilitate trading.
Discussion
Loading…
How it resolves
Settled on-chain by UMA's optimistic oracle: once an outcome is clear, anyone can propose the result, which then enters a challenge window where it can be disputed with evidence before it finalizes.
⚖️ A proposed outcome can be disputed during a challenge window before it's final.
Resolution criteria
This market will resolve to "O 86.5" if the New York Yankees win more than 86.5 games during the 2026 MLB Regular Season. If at any point it becomes statistically impossible for the New York Yankees to record more than 86.5 wins per the rules of the MLB, the corresponding market will resolve to "U 86.5". If the MLB Regular Season is cancelled, partially completed, or postponed after November 30, 2026, 11:59 PM ET, this market will resolve to "50-50". The resolution source will be official information from Major League Baseball (https://www.mlb.com/standings/); however a consensus of credible reporting may also be used.
ⓘ A market settles under its own written rules, which can lag what looks decided in the news — so the price may not move to 100% the moment an outcome seems obvious.
View the official rules on Polymarket ↗Related markets
3M Open Winner
Jackson Koivun commands an unusually high 54% probability for a PGA Tour event, but the 1-point dip in the last 24 hours hints at shifting money, and recent headlines focus entirely on the British Open victory by Ryan Fox (AP News, Jul 24), offering no clear catalyst for that movement or for Koivun's lead itself.
66 outcomes
Mohamed Salah will join PSG by September 1, 2026
Liverpool are actively blocking a PSG move for Mohamed Salah by pursuing his replacement and even bidding for a PSG target, making a transfer highly unlikely despite persistent rumors.
Yes ≈ 5% chance
Preston Stout (T20) vs OTHER
The field is extremely concentrated on 'OTHER' at 92%, with Preston Stout at just 8%, reflecting that Stout is a niche T20 golfer with no recent PGA Tour headlines, while the 'OTHER' category encompasses the entire PGA Tour field, which has been generating multiple headlines about players like J.T. Poston and Taylor Pendrith making notable shots in recent weeks.
2 outcomes
Kansas City vs Detroit
Despite Detroit's slight lead, Kansas City's recent win and Salvador Perez's franchise home-run record have significantly narrowed the gap, making this a near toss-up.
2 outcomes