Will the Supreme Court overturn gay marriage?
1 markets · 2y
The market strongly favors No (92%) for overturning same-sex marriage before 2029, reflecting the absence of a direct legal challenge and the high bar for overturning a widely accepted precedent, but the Dobbs analogy keeps a non-trivial tail risk alive.
📊 Base rate: Historically, the Supreme Court overrules its own constitutional precedents in fewer than 0.5% of cases, but the 2022 Dobbs decision (overturning Roe v. Wade) established a recent precedent for overturning a widely accepted social-rights ruling, raising the baseline risk above that historical rate.
What's driving it
- • No clear catalyst recently; the 92% No odds imply the market sees Obergefell as settled law, with no active Supreme Court case or pending legislation threatening it.
- • The conservative 6-3 majority has not taken up any gay-marriage case since 2015, and the Court has shown reluctance to revisit certain settled precedents despite its ideological tilt.
- • Public opinion (over 70% support for same-sex marriage) and the 2022 Respect for Marriage Act, which codified federal recognition, create political and legal barriers to overturning Obergefell.
The bullish case
- • A conservative majority could use the Dobbs reasoning—that the Constitution does not provide a right to same-sex marriage—to return the issue to states, especially if a case like a state ban reaches the Court.
- • The Court could grant certiorari in a case from a state that passes a new anti-gay-marriage law, providing a vehicle to overturn Obergefell.
- • The market may be underpricing the possibility that the Court, emboldened by Dobbs, will revisit Obergefell in a future term, particularly if a justice is replaced with a more conservative appointee.
The bearish case
- • Obergefell has been the law for over a decade with no successful challenge; the Court has repeatedly denied cert in cases that could have weakened it.
- • The Respect for Marriage Act (2022) requires federal recognition of same-sex marriages, meaning even if Obergefell is overturned, many states would still recognize such marriages, reducing the practical incentive for a challenge.
- • The current conservative justices have not indicated interest in overturning Obergefell, and Justice Gorsuch (a Trump appointee) wrote the majority opinion in Bostock v. Clayton County, which protected LGBTQ+ workplace rights, suggesting a nuanced view.
What to watch
- • The Supreme Court's 2026 term (starting October 2026): if the Court grants certiorari in a case threatening same-sex marriage, the No probability would drop sharply.
- • A state legislature (e.g., in Texas or Florida) passing a law banning same-sex marriage in 2027 would create a direct legal challenge, increasing the Yes probability.
- • A change in the Court's composition due to a justice's retirement or death before 2029 could shift the odds, especially if replaced by a more conservative or more liberal nominee.
AI-generated · grounded in recent news + odds · informational only, not advice. Verify on the source platform.
Markets in this event
Will the Supreme Court overturn marriage equality? — Before 2029
Yes ≈ 9% chance
Data from Kalshi’s public API, for informational purposes only. PredictPal is not affiliated with any platform and does not facilitate trading.
Discussion
Loading…